
"Yeah, I did review WALL-E... but, um... well, even though I posted it on Listal last September (when I joined), the review was actually written in the summer of 2008, when I had only recently begun th"

"Well, it's not so much that we disagree on WALL-E as it is that our emotional reactions to it were completely different. You're right in all the points you make about it, though - there definitely ar"

"I could NEVER disagree with someone who thought "The Exploding Girl" is a movie that meanders frequently, because it absolutely is. In these slice-of-life dramas, one of the factors that I think will"

"1. Stanley Kubrick 2. Quentin Tarantino 3. Richard Linklater 4. Gus Van Sant 5. Joel and Ethan Coen 6. Michael Haneke 7. Joseph L. Mankiewicz 8. Louis Malle 9. Billy Wilder 10. David Fincher"

"1. Naomi Watts 2. Cate Blanchett 3. Chris Cooper 4. Joan Allen 5. Frances McDormand 6. River Phoenix 7. Faye Dunaway 8. Joseph Gordon-Levitt 9. Laura Linney 10. Julianne Moore"

"Yep, I saw WE DON'T LIVE HERE ANYMORE, and she was very good in it. The performance that enthralls me to no end and that probably made me "fall in love with her" as an actress, though, is the one she"

"lol @ The Tourist. Naomi Watts is my favorite actress, which is why I wanted to LOVE Fair Game, but man, the last few minutes of that movie were sooo UN-subtle in basically jamming the film's polit"

"Well done - I especially agree with your comments on Inglourious Basterds, The Last Samurai, Zombieland and Titanic."

"Couldn't agree more that the LOTR trilogy deserves to be right at the top. :)"

"Just to reiterate what poetik_tragedy already said... once you see HARD CANDY, it'll easily become the #1 performance on your list. She's very good in everything she's done, but in HARD CANDY, she's "

"I definitely liked THE LOVELY BONES a lot less than you did (read: I hated it), but one point from your review that I agree on very strongly is that it would've benefited a lot from being rated R inst"

"FARGO and NO COUNTRY FOR OLD MEN are my top two as well, though I still haven't seen four of their films."

"Awesome!! Thanks for doing this list. Linklater is wonderful, and those top two movies hold a super special place in my movie heart. I haven't yet made an all-time list of my favorite films, becaus"

"I saw ALL ABOUT EVE for the first time ever just a couple of days ago, and have to admit Bette Davis was freaking terrific in it."

"First of all, thanks so much for giving credit to my review of THE ADJUSTMENT BUREAU. :) I did think the movie was fine for a March release, but man, the movie gets terribly ponderous at times. I co"

"Thanks for asking me for suggestions! Here's what I'd say: From ALL ABOUT EVE - Margo and Eve From 2001: A SPACE ODYSSEY - HAL 9000 From NETWORK - Howard Beale From FARGO - Marge From KILL BILL VOL."

"American Beauty, Eyes Wide Shut, Magnolia, The Blair Witch Project and The War Zone are ALL among my favorite films - it's awesome to see them all here, particularly a movie as great and devastating a"

"Great list - I think Reynolds is actually fantastic at serious dramatic roles, and that he should start veering more in that direction. He was great as a secondary character in Adventureland, and eve"

"The Return of the King and Spider-Man 2 are two of the most immersive, most awesome experiences I've had at a movie theater with a "blockbuster"-type film. There hasn't been much that has topped thos"

"This reminds me that I haven't had my Before Sunrise/Before Sunset fix this year yet, and that I should get on that soon - I can't ever get tired of watching them. Good to see that you liked Rabbit H"

"I strongly agree on SHERLOCK HOLMES - I didn't like it in the least bit, and I've no idea why a slew of other people like it. It's a lackluster movie at best. I couldn't be less excited about the se"

"Hahahaha... okay, I'll admit that, even though I didn't turn it off after 30 minutes, I WANTED to. My problem is that, as much as I might hate a movie, I always hesitate to shut it off before it's ov"

"I'll have to check out Black Dynamite and Thirst, but once again, great list. I'm glad that someone else appreciated A Serious Man as much as I did. "Accept mystery" is one of the movie lines I laug"

"Terrific. I'm glad that someone else actually saw MOTHER and gave it the commendation it deserves. If the film had gotten a wider distribution, I think Kim Hye-Ja would've easily been in contention "

"Awesome. Parvati and Cirie are easily my top two as well. I love how they obliterated the guys in Micronesia."

"I'm glad you included Fair Game here. I had some serious problems with the way certain aspects are handled in the final act, but if I were to make a list of my favorite actors, Naomi Watts would be r"

"Oooh, I need to pick up Fantastic Mr. Fox as soon as I can. I haven't been a fan of Wes Anderson's films, but there are many who have said this one was a vast improvement on the rest of his material."